Kish Troyer is living the dream, playing baseball in the minor leagues, when life throws him a curve ball. Injuries take him out of the game he loves. Permanently. Kish decides to return to his home in the Amish community of Michigan?s Upper Peninsula and open a hunting, fishing, and outdoor sports shop?while trying to stay clear of the woman who broke his heart. Twice. Naomi Kaiser is determined to stay as far away from the handsome Kish Troyer as possible. Hurt her once, shame on him; hurt her twice, shame on her. Hurt her three times? Not happening. But what?s a girl to do when he keeps showing up at her bakery? Naomi decides to introduce Kish to some other single Amish women. That will work, right? Between Naomi arranging blind dates, which Kish tries to avoid, and his bakery visits, the two declare a truce. But is that enough to revive an old season of two too many strikeouts?